Sažetak | Glazba ima važnu ulogu u životu adolescenata jer doprinosi njihovu kognitivnom razvoju, samopoimanju, vršnjačkoj socijalizaciji i društvenoj percepciji te im pomaže pri regulaciji raspoloženja. Cilj ovog istraživanja bio je ispitati funkcije koje glazba ima u životu adolescenata, njihove glazbene preferencije i osobine ličnosti kao važan faktor u procesu formiranja glazbenog ukusa, uz kontrolu sociodemografskih varijabli spola, školskog uspjeha i glazbenog obrazovanja sudionika.
U teorijskom dijelu disertacije uputilo se na čimbenike koji utječu na glazbene preferencije: osobine glazbe, osobine slušatelja, konteksti slušanja glazbe, mediji i osobine ličnosti. Objašnjeni su i teorijski modeli glazbenih preferencija: Interaktivna teorija glazbenih preferencija (LeBlanc, 1981), Recipročni model reakcije na glazbu (Hargreaves i sur., 2005) i Revidirani recipročni model reakcije na glazbu (Hargreaves i sur., 2012). Osobine ličnosti, kao značajan faktor koji vrši utjecaj na glazbene preferencije pojedinca, definirane su kroz nekoliko teorija ličnosti. Poseban naglasak stavljen je na Petfaktorski model ličnosti (Costa i McCrae, 1992) kao najpoznatiji model ličnosti koji se temelji na leksičkom pristupu, a koji je upotrjebljen u provedenom istraživanju. Model obuhvaća pet glavnih čimbenika osobnosti koji određuju ličnost: ekstraverzija/introverzija, neuroticizam-emocionalna stabilnost, ugodnost, savjesnost i intelekt (Dobrota i Reić Ercegovac, 2016).
U poglavlju o funkcijama glazbe problematiziraju se razlozi slušanja glazbe u adolescenciji, poruke koje mladi dobivaju preko glazbe te funkcije glazbe u prevenciji i intervenciji kod adolescenata. U okviru poglavlja o funkcijama glazbe primjenjuje se klasifikacija funkcija glazbe prema modelu Boer i sur. (2012) poznatom kao Respect-Music Scale koja obuhvaća deset faktora: funkcija društvenog povezivanja glazbom s prijateljima; funkcija društvenog povezivanja glazbom s obitelji; funkcija otpuštanja; emocionalna funkcija slušanja glazbe; glazba u funkciji plesa; pozadinska funkcija glazbe; glazba u funkciji fokusa; glazba u funkciji izražavanja političkih stavova; funkcija kulturnog identiteta i glazba u funkciji izražavanja osobnih vrijednosti.
Empirijsko istraživanje provedeno je u Splitu među maturantima I. gimnazije / Jezične, III. gimnazije / Prirodoslovno-matematičke, IV. gimnazije „Marko Marulić“ i V. gimnazije „Vladimir Nazor“. U istraživanju je sudjelovalo 295 učenika (Ž = 166, M = 129). Veći dio istraživanja proveden je sredinom drugog polugodišta 2019./2020. školske godine, nakon čega su škole zatvorene zbog globalne pandemije COVID-19 virusa, pa je drugi dio istraživanja (30 % upitnika) proveden početkom prvog polugodišta 2020./2021. Anketni se upitnik sastojao od četiriju dijelova: upitnik Osobine slušatelja, upitnik IPIP-50 Junior S (Mlačić i Goldberg, 2007), upitnik Respect-Music Scale (Boer i Fischer, 2011) te Upitnik glazbenih preferencija STOMP (Short Test of Music Preferences) (Rentfrow i Gosling, 2003).
Upitnik Osobine slušatelja sadržavao je 12 pitanja zatvorenog tipa kojima su prikupljeni podaci o sociodemografskim karakteristikama sudionika: dobi i spolu, školskom uspjehu, aktivnostima slobodnog vremena te glazbenom iskustvu adolescenata. U drugom dijelu anketnog upitnika ispitane su osobine ličnosti adolescenata upitnikom IPIP-50 Junior S (Mlačić i Goldberg, 2007) koji je sadržavao 50 tvrdnji kojima su opisana uobičajena ponašanja djece i mladih. Ovih je 50 tvrdnji podijeljeno na pet osobina ličnosti, pri čemu je svaku mjerilo 10 tvrdnji. Zadatak sudionika bio je da na ljestvici Likertova tipa procijene koliko se određena tvrdnja odnosi na njih. Treći dio upitnika odnosio se na funkcije glazbe u životu adolescenata i istražen je uz pomoć Respect-Music Scale te se sastojao od 45 tvrdnji. U odnosu na početnu verziju Skale izostavljeno je deset tvrdnji koje nisu bile dovoljno saturirane niti jednim od devet ekstrahiranih faktora. Konačna verzija skale sastojala se od 35 tvrdnji. Provedbom eksploratorne faktorske analize uz varimaks rotaciju ekstrahirano je devet faktora, jer su pozadinska funkcija glazbe i glazba u funkciji fokusa spojene u jedan faktor – fokusiranje. Devet ekstrahiranih korijena objasnilo je 73.399 % varijance funkcija glazbe. U četvrtom dijelu anketnog upitnika ispitane su glazbene preferencije adolescenata uz pomoć upitnika STOMP koji je sadržavao 16 glazbenih ulomaka podijeljenih u četiri glazbena stila: refleksno-kompleksni (klasična glazba, jazz, blues i folk); intenzivno-buntovni (rock, alternativna i heavy metal); veselo-konvencionalni (pop, country, religijska i filmska glazba); i energično-ritmični (rap/hip-hop, soul/funk i elektronička/plesna glazba) (Rentfrow i Gosling, 2003). Od svakog glazbenog stila izabrane su po četiri skladbe reprezentanti glazbenog stila. Skladbe istog stila nisu slušane jedna za drugom, a uz faktor sviđanja određene skladbe sudionici su zaokružili i poznatost pojedine skladbe. Primjenom eksploratorne faktorske analize provjerena je faktorska struktura upitnika Glazbenih preferencija sa svih 16 čestica, no dobivena struktura nije replicirala izvornu i očekivanu 4-faktorsku strukturu. Provjerom pouzdanosti četiriju pretpostavljenih faktora uočeno je da sve čestice energično-ritmičnog stila
imaju nisku pouzdanost te da jedna čestica veselo-konvencionalnog stila značajno narušava inače zadovoljavajuću pouzdanost tog faktora. Nakon izostavljanja tih pet čestica glazbenih ulomaka provedena je konfirmatorna faktorska analiza na tri faktora.
S obzirom na postavljeni cilj istraživanja, definirana su tri problema: 1) provjeriti faktorsku strukturu Upitnika funkcija glazbe i Skale glazbenih preferencija i njihovih metrijskih karakteristika; 2) ispitati povezanost između sociodemografskih značajki, osobina ličnosti, funkcija glazbe i glazbenih preferencija; 3) utvrditi pojedinačni doprinos sociodemografskih karakteristika, osobina ličnosti i funkcija glazbe u objašnjenju varijance glazbenih preferencija različitih glazbenih stilova. U skladu s navedenim problemima istraživanja oblikovana je hipoteza u kojoj se pretpostavilo da će sve skupine prediktora značajno doprinositi objašnjenju varijance glazbenih preferencija, da će funkcije glazbe biti pozitivno povezane s glazbenim preferencijama i s određenim osobinama ličnosti te da će osobine ličnosti, pogotovo otvorenost za iskustva, značajno doprinijeti objašnjenju varijance glazbenih preferencija. Također, jedno od polaznih očekivanja bilo je da će sudionice sve funkcije glazbe procjenjivati važnijima u odnosu na sudionike.
Rezultati istraživanja pokazali su povezanost svih glazbenih stilova sa sociodemografskim značajkama (spol i više ocjene) i sa svim funkcijama glazbe osim političke funkcije i funkcije kulturnog identiteta te s osobinama ličnosti od kojih su se najviše istaknule ugodnost i intelekt. Spol kao važna determinanta glazbenih preferencija u provedenom istraživanju pokazala je pozitivnu povezanost sa svim funkcijama glazbe osim političkom, funkcijom kulturnog identiteta i duhovnom. Što se tiče školskog uspjeha, ocjene su se u provedenom istraživanju pokazale kao sociodemografski faktor koji ima veliku povezanost s glazbenim preferencijama adolescenata. Glazbeno obrazovanje sudionika nije se pokazalo bitnim faktorom u vezi s glazbenim preferencijama, što se može objasniti relativno malim udjelom sudionika koji su imali glazbeno obrazovanje (16.6 %). Najveća povezanost između glazbenih preferencija i osobina ličnosti u provedenom istraživanju pokazala se u osobinama ugodnosti i intelekta. Ugodnost se istaknula kao najvažniji korelat glazbenih preferencija kao crta osobnosti koja je pokazala pozitivnu povezanost s osobinama savjesnosti i emocionalnom stabilnosti, dok se intelekt pokazao povezan s reflesivno-kompleksnim glazbenim stilom koji obuhvaća klasičnu i jazz glazbu. Socijalna se funkcija glazbe u provedenom istraživanju pokazala najvažnijom, i to kroz funkciju glazbe socijalnog povezivanja
s obitelji kroz sva tri glazbena stila. Budući da je 2020. bila godina proglašenja globalne pandemije virusa COVID-19, rezultat se pokazao očekivanim s obzirom na kontekst u kojem je provedeno istraživanje, jer je taj vremenski period bio bitno obilježen izrazito strogim mjerama poput zatvaranja (tzv. „lockdowna“), socijalne distance i zabrane društvenih događaja i okupljanja. Uz funkciju socijalnog povezivanja s obitelji, adolescentima se također istaknulo važnim i socijalno povezivanje s prijateljima, najviše kroz popularnu glazbu koja pripada veselo-konvencionalnom stilu.
Na temelju rezultata dobivenih istraživanjem može se zaključiti da je adolescentima gimnazijalcima glazba jako bitna. Glazba predstavlja važnu aktivnost njihova slobodnog vremena i vrijednosti koje proizlaze iz funkcija glazbe, glazbenih preferencija i osobina ličnosti sve su usmjerene na zajedništvo i socijalizaciju. S obzirom na to da su se društvene funkcije glazbe pokazale najvažnije u životu adolescenata, može se pretpostaviti da je grupni rad jedan od načina kako se ove vrijednosti mogu iskoristiti u nastavnom procesu. Kroz grupni rad bi se na satovima glazbene umjetnosti adolescentima pomoglo u njihovu sazrijevanju da bolje razumiju glazbu, a zatim i da se njome funkcionalnije koriste. |
Sažetak (engleski) | Music plays a vital role in the life of adolescents contributing to their cognitive development, self-perception, peer socialization and social perception, and helping them regulate their mood. This research was aimed to examine the functions that music has in the life of adolescents, their musical preferences and personality traits as important factors in forming musical taste, while controlling for the sociodemographic variables of gender, school success and musical education of the participants.
In the theoretical part of the dissertation, the following factors influencing musical preferences were referred to: music characteristics, listener characteristics, music listening context, media and personality traits. Furthermore, these theoretical models of musical preferences were explained: Interactive Theory of Music Preferences (LeBlanc, 1981), Reciprocal-Feedback Model of Response to Music (Hargreaves et al., 2005) and Revised Reciprocal-Feedback Model of Response to Music (Hargreaves et al., 2012). Personality traits, as a significant factor influencing an individual’s musical preferences, have been defined through several personality theories. Special emphasis was placed on the Five-Factor Personality Model (Costa and McCrae, 1992) as the most famous personality model based on the lexical approach, which was used in the research. The model includes five main personality factors that determine personality: extraversion/introversion, neuroticism-emotional stability, agreeableness, conscientiousness and intellect (Dobrota and Reić Ercegovac, 2016).
The chapter on the functions of music addresses the reasons for listening to music in adolescence, the messages that young people receive through music, and the function of music in prevention and intervention in adolescents. In this chapter, we have applied the classification of the functions of music according to the model proposed by Boer et al. (2012) known as the Respect-Music Scale, which includes ten factors: the function of social bonding through music with friends; family bonding; venting; emotions; dance; background function; focus; politic; cultural identity and expressing personal values.
Empirical research was conducted in Split among graduates of three high schools: 1st Secondary School of Languages, 3rd Secondary School with Extended Program in Science and Mathematics,“Vladimir Nazor”. A total of 295 students participated in the research (F = 166, M = 129). Most of the survey was conducted in the middle of the second semester of 2019/2020, after which schools were closed due to the global pandemic of the COVID-19 virus, so the second part of the survey (30% of the questionnaire) was conducted at the beginning of the first semester of 2020/2021. The questionnaire consisted of four parts: the Listener Characteristics Questionnaire, the IPIP-50 Junior S Questionnaire (Mlačić and Goldberg, 2007), the Respect-Music Scale (Boer and Fischer, 2011) and the STOMP (Short Test of Music Preferences) Questionnaire (Rentfrow and Gosling, 2003).
The Listener Characteristics Questionnaire contained 12 closed-ended questions that collected data on the sociodemographic characteristics of the participants: age and gender, school performance, leisure activities and musical experience of adolescents. In the second part of the questionnaire, the personality traits of adolescents were examined using the IPIP-50 Junior S Questionnaire (Mlačić and Goldberg, 2007), which contained 50 items describing the usual behaviors of children and young people. These 50 statements are divided into five personality traits, each of which is measured by 10 items. The task of the participants was to evaluate on a Likert-type scale how much a certain item applies to them. The third part of the questionnaire referred to the functions of music in the life of adolescents. It contained the Respect-Music Scale and consisted of 45 items. Compared to the initial version of the Scale, ten statements were omitted that were not sufficiently saturated with any of the nine extracted factors. The final version of the Scale consisted of 35 statements. By performing exploratory factor analysis with varimax rotation, nine factors were extracted, because the background and the focus function of music were combined into one factor – focusing. The nine extracted roots explained 73.399 % of the variance of the music functions. In the fourth part of the questionnaire, the musical preferences of adolescents were examined with the help of the STOMP questionnaire, which contained 16 musical excerpts divided into four musical styles: reflexive-complex (classical music, jazz, blues and folk); intense-rebellious (rock, alternative and heavy metal); upbeat-conventional (pop, country, religious and film music); and energetic-rhythmic (rap/hip-hop, soul/funk and electronic/dance music) (Rentfrow and Gosling, 2003). From each musical style, four representative compositions of the musical style were chosen. Compositions of the same style were not listened to consecutively, and in addition to the factor of liking a certain composition, the
148
participants also indicated the familiarity of an individual composition. By applying exploratory factor analysis, the factor structure of the Music Preferences Questionnaire with all 16 items was verified, but the resulting structure did not replicate the original and expected 4-factor structure. By checking the reliability of the four assumed factors, it was observed that all items of the energetic-rhythmic style have low reliability and that one item of the upbeat-conventional style significantly impairs the otherwise satisfactory reliability of that factor. After omitting those five items of musical excerpts, a confirmatory factor analysis was conducted on three factors.
With regard to the set goal of the research, three problems were defined: 1) to check the factor structure of the Music Functions Questionnaire and Music Preferences Scale and their metrical characteristics; 2) to examine the connection between sociodemographic characteristics, personality traits, functions of music and musical preferences; 3) determine the individual contribution of sociodemographic characteristics, personality traits and functions of music in explaining the variance of musical preferences of different musical styles. In accordance with the mentioned research problems, a hypothesis was formulated according to which all groups of predictors will significantly contribute to the explanation of the variance of musical preferences, that the functions of music will be positively related to musical preferences and to certain personality traits, and that personality traits, especially openness to experience, will significantly contribute to the explanation of the variance of musical preferences. In addition, one of the initial expectations was that female participants would rate all functions of music as more important compared to male participants.
The results of the research showed that all musical styles are correlated with sociodemographic features (gender and higher grades) and all functions of music, except the political function and the function of cultural identity, and with personality traits, particularly agreeableness and intellect. Gender as an important determinant of musical preferences in the conducted research showed a positive correlation with all functions of music except political, the function of cultural identity and spiritual function of music. As for school success, it was found that grades are a sociodemographic factor that has a strong correlation with the musical preferences of adolescents. The musical education of the participants did not prove to be an important factor in relation to musical preferences, which can be explained by the relatively small proportion of participants who had a musical education (16.6%). The greatest correlation between musical
149
preferences and personality traits in the conducted research was shown in the traits of agreeableness and intellect. Agreeableness was the most important correlate of musical preferences as a personality trait positively correlated with the traits of conscientiousness and emotional stability, while intellect was shown to be correlated with a reflexive-complex musical style that includes classical and jazz music. The social function of music was found to be the most important, through the function of social bonding with the family in all three musical styles. Since 2020 was the year of the global pandemic of the COVID-19 virus, the result turned out to be expected considering the context in which the research was conducted, because that time period was significantly marked by extremely strict measures such as lockdown, social distancing and bans on social events and gatherings. In addition to social bonding with the family, social bonding with friends proved to be important for adolescents, mostly through popular music that belongs to the upbeat-conventional style.
Based on the results of the research, it can be concluded that music is very important to adolescents. Music represents an important leisure activity and the values that derive from the functions of music, musical preferences and personality traits are all aimed at togetherness and socialization. Social functions of music were found to be the most important in the life of adolescents; therefore, it can be assumed that group work is one of the ways in which these values can be used in teaching. Group work in music lessons could help adolescents mature and understand music better, and consequently to use it more functionally. |